May 25, 2022


Your Partner in the Digital Era

Federal Investigator Says Laptop or computer Evidence Is Damning

FAYETTEVILLE, Arkansas — Thumbnail photographs of child sexual abuse content that investigators say they discovered on the work pc of former 19 Youngsters and Counting truth star Josh Duggar — in addition to substantial geolocation data — demonstrate that he was dependable for downloading the incriminating product, prosecutors argued Friday.

Expert witness testimony could link Duggar to the boy or girl sexual abuse products he was charged with “knowingly” acquiring and possessing in April. He pleaded not responsible and faces up to 20 several years in prison and a fantastic of up to $250,000 for every count if he is convicted.

In courtroom, federal prosecutor William Clayman asked James Fottrell, a prime forensics investigator at the Office of Justice, about the in-depth forensic examination he conducted by means of Duggar’s perform computer system at Wholesale Motorcars.

“Based on [your] review, who was present at the automobile great deal each time baby pornography was downloaded?” Clayman questioned.

“Josh Duggar,” Fottrell explained.

Fottrell’s testimony concerned a moment-by-minute analysis evaluating when child sexual abuse products had been downloaded on a discreet “partition” of the workplace computer with the time and area of shots and messages on Duggar’s outdated Apple iphone 8. Fottrell was equipped to entry the backup of the mobile phone through Duggar’s particular MacBook Pro. The instances of the downloads on the perform laptop correlated with Iphone photos Duggar took at the car or truck lot, as very well as text messages he despatched from the cell phone determining he was at do the job, Fottrell testified.

Not only did the cellphone level to Duggar staying at the great deal, but any baby sexual abuse product on the operate computer system would have experienced to be downloaded manually, Fottrell mentioned. Which is because the computer system experienced a little something recognised as a Linux partition, in which the pc is fundamentally “split” into two distinctive running methods — just one Microsoft Home windows, the other Linux. In get to decide on the Linux aspect, Fottrell claimed, another person would need to bodily strike a keyboard command.

Remote obtain would not have authorized that functionality, he added, contradicting the defense’s assertion produced in cross-assessment that a distant user could have downloaded the components on the workplace computer alternatively than Duggar himself.

Fottrell stated that though the “possibility exists” for distant entry to the Linux technique, what he identified on the laptop “doesn’t fit” that principle.

The protection also questioned the speed and efficacy of Fottrell’s search, together with a insignificant incident in which the web turned on all through his research by means of the personal computer, some thing that could have influenced the viability of the proof. But Fottrell claimed this had “minimal” result on his proof and conclusions.

Fottrell reviewed with the jury an substantial timeline he compiled centered on his conclusions from Duggar’s laptop or computer and Iphone backup immediately after they were confiscated from Wholesale Motorcars by way of a look for warrant in November 2019.

The phone’s person took a photograph at the motor vehicle large amount on May well 11, and the Linux partition was downloaded the similar day, Fottrell claimed. On Could 13, the partition was mounted in the afternoon close to the exact same time the phone had a photo of a scale established to be in the lot’s office environment, he extra.

Fottrell stated he discovered a image dated May perhaps 14 in the Iphone back-up that featured the HP computer’s monitor with a YouTube video pulled up. A reflection of whoever is sitting down at the place of work desk is visible, as is the baseball hat they are donning with the Wholesale Motorcars symbol on it. Fottrell said he identified a picture taken that exact working day in the Iphone again-up of Duggar and his wife Anna evidently shopping together — Duggar donning a baseball cap with the Wholesale Motorcars’ brand.

By way of textual content messages, Duggar experienced identified he was at the auto good deal on May well 14.

Also on that exact working day, Fottrell stated there was proof that bookmarks ended up created on an anonymous browser termed uTorrent in the Linux partition for internet sites involved with baby sexual abuse materials, and thumbnails for express material of insignificant ladies were developed.

“I’m on the auto ton now,” Duggar claimed in a text the early morning of Could 15. Minutes later on, Fottrell mentioned a file involving a small female offering oral sexual intercourse was downloaded on the Linux partition by way of an anonymous browser identified as uTorrent. Minutes later, a lot more youngster sexual abuse information were downloaded from uTorrent.

The skilled spelled out that computer systems fundamentally make tiny “thumbnail” illustrations or photos for just about every complete-size image on the product. Fottrell said he identified thumbnails of this little one sexual abuse written content in the computer’s backend in his assessment, which means full-sized variations of these resources and other boy or girl abuse materials he also detected should have been there at some stage.

Later on that working day, shots on the telephone of a firetruck and an accident in close proximity to the automobile lot had been taken.

Also on Could 15, the user of the cellphone sent a textual content concept indicating that they would be keeping at the car lot right up until about 6 p.m. Shortly just after, a file “” was downloaded from an nameless browser on the Linux partition and thumbnails of the file were being made, indicating that the files were seen, Fottrell mentioned. The “Marissa series,” he spelled out, is a nicely-acknowledged and remarkably traded sequence of boy or girl sexual abuse content material showcasing the exact same woman in a number of specific poses, some nude.

The timing of the down load aligns with the identical instant that detective Amber Kalmer, who testified this week that her checking software package flagged anyone with an IP address in Springdale, Arkansas, downloading kid sexual abuse resources. Kalmer was capable to accessibility the file herself, which involved 65 images of the similar minor lady in express poses.

In a further, on Could 16, a thumbnail of a approximately 30-minute online video was developed just two minutes right before a image of a sticky take note on the desk in Wholesale Motorcars’ office was taken, Fottrell explained the iPhone’s backup showed.

The password “Intel1988” was also “ubiquitously used” by Duggar for around five a long time to accessibility a selection of accounts, together with the Linux partition, Fottrell uncovered.

By way of examination of Duggar’s personalized MacBook Pro, Fottrell uncovered the exact same password or iterations of it, applied across his bank accounts and purposes.

Other probable evidence concerned a report from Covenant Eyes, the anti-porn computer software Duggar and his spouse Anna experienced made use of that generated normal studies on each individual other’s exposure. Fottrell cited a report from the software package, dated 2017, flagging that Duggar experienced attempted to download uTorrent and the service blocked him. The report and similar entries showed that he experienced made multiple attempts to accessibility the very same nameless browser the witness would locate on the Linux partition that was ultimately applied to down load kid sexual abuse products.

More, Fottrell mentioned he identified that the “not long ago played” background of a media participant another person would have set up on the Linux partition indicated that documents identified to include kid sexual abuse components were being “streamed” appropriate from the workplace computer system, fairly than an web supply.

Duggar attained common fame and a conservative adhering to for his time on TLC’s 19 Children and Counting, which tracked the ever-increasing relatives of his moms and dads, Jim Bob and Michelle Duggar. Their big home and ultraconservative beliefs also led to spinoffs. But in a 2015 Fox News interview, Josh Duggar admitted that he experienced molested five girls when he was a teenager, which include his four young sisters and a loved ones babysitter. In the interview, the household explained he and the ladies acquired counseling and that they did not believe that there was any long run risk of wrongdoing in their view, he had only been “curious about ladies.”

Duggar has been current for the previous three days at court with his spouse, Anna, sitting in the gallery with other loved ones associates. The few exited the gallery keeping hands through the court’s afternoon recess. His brother-in-legislation Derick Dillard has sat subsequent to Anna for the very last a few days. His wife, Duggar’s estranged sister Jill Duggar, has been advised as a prospective witness in the circumstance.